Casualties of the Cashless Society: Those Who Get Seasonal Tips

As 2018 looms, the sunrise of a cashless society feels handy. Disagree with it? Try throwing a couple $20 payments at the table subsequent time you’re splitting the check. Or better yet, ask absolutely everyone not status behind coins sign…

As 2018 looms, the sunrise of a cashless society feels handy. Disagree with it? Try throwing a couple $20 payments at the table subsequent time you’re splitting the check. Or better yet, ask absolutely everyone not status behind coins sign in to break a $10 invoice.

While the upward thrust of Venmo, Uber, Seamless, and Bitcoin et al. have made it nearly gauche in certain circles to flash a wallet thick with payments, there are many urban people for whom the shift faraway from cash represents a severe financial hassle. Doormen, elevator operators, manicurists — any employee predicated on small, spontaneous cash guidelines — are finding themselves neglected inside the cold through an increasingly more cashless international.


“These guys, they don’t tip like they used to, due to the fact they don’t have the coins of their wallet like they used to,” said Mark, an elevator operator at an upscale Manhattan co-op, speak approximately his building’s tenants. He asked to apply simplest his first call because his union and agency forbid him from talking to the click.

It’s a peculiar quirk of modern-day metropolis life. The inventory marketplace is on fire, unemployment is down, and the average charge of a Manhattan condominium is now more than $2 million. Yet true good fortune finding all of us with paper cash in her purse.

Earlier this year, a U.S. Bank survey discovered that fifty percent of Americans convey coins with them handiest about half of the time. In every other recent survey, just 11 percent of Americans selected cash as their favored shape of payment, a far-off 1/3 to credit score playing cards (forty percentage) and debit playing cards (35 percent).

Continue analyzing the primary tale


Holiday Tipping: A Fraught Apartment Building Tradition DEC. Sixteen, 2017

With More Tipping Options Comes More Confusion APRIL 17, 2017


Thanks to Venmo, We Now All Know How Cheap Our Friends Are JULY 21, 2017

360 VIEW
Tips on Doorman Tipping and Other Holiday Traditions DEC. Sixteen, 2016


Cash Is King No More APRIL 22, 2017

Continue reading the primary story

For many human beings, particularly in dense urban environments, there’s simply no incentive to visit the A.T.M. Whilst cab rides, coffee, pizza shipping, or even snacks from food vans may be paid for online or with plastic. And that’s terrible news for any employee now not taking part in the virtual economic system.

The trouble is mainly acute for condo constructing the team of workers like doormen and elevator operators, who aren’t a part of any transaction concerning their “patron” and typically rely on exchange from cab rides or food delivery for their tips.

“Long ago, the tenants could take a cab home, and they paid with coins,” Mark said. “So if they get change out of that $20, they come up with that exchange.

“Now they swipe a card inside the cab, or while they arrive with the Uber, they don’t pay, so that they just stroll out of the car and they go directly up.”

Mark says that his tips have long passed from $400 per week 3 years ago to, at maximum, $one hundred per week in 2017.

Roger Johnston, who has become a Manhattan doorman in 2004 after operating on Wall Street for 31 years, blamed no longer just the cashless society but also the overall economic system and residing fee. “These guys, they’re paying right cash — nearly 5 grand for a one-bedroom,” he stated. “A cup of espresso is an alternate, so a variety of those human beings, they hire right here and stroll to work. It’s just the economic system.”


Mr. Johnston said his recommendations have dropped 60 percent because of 2008, whilst he took his cutting-edge activity in a Park Avenue building.

But any other doorman at a one of a kind Park Avenue building, who also asked anonymity, said it changed into specifically his tenants’ choice for virtual services that has all but eliminated his tip earnings. They order the whole lot online, he stated, consisting of Uber, meals, and water. Even the hints for the delivery guys, he said, are online.

He doesn’t blame the tenants. However, he is frustrated with the situation. The doorman said he may want to work a complete shift and nevertheless no longer make any guidelines.

As everyday gratuities have faded, holiday tips stuffed into greeting playing cards — usually a vital element in a doorman’s profits — have emerged as extra critical than ever. Unfortunately, those envelopes are not pretty as complete as they were once, Mr. Johnston said.

People who don’t convey coins aren’t oblivious to the plight of these employees. Maya Chung, 27, hasn’t carried paper money because she was a teen, as an alternative relying on a mixture of virtual apps, PayPal, and plastic to get via her day. Her building in the Crown Heights neighborhood of Brooklyn doesn’t have a doorman. However, when she visits the nail salon, she invariably finds herself embarrassed now not to have cash for gratuities.

“Every time I go there without cash, they omit out on their recommendations cause they don’t have the mechanism to position it on the credit card, and I always feel awful,” stated Ms. Chung, a digital reporter at InsideEdition.Com. Still, she can’t seem to consider going to the A.T.M. Before she is going. “I’m just now not thinking about it because I’m so programmed to never have cash on me.”

Not all workers who depend on guidelines are harm with the aid of the shift faraway from cash. To the contrary, contact-display screen capsules in cabs and coffeehouses that set off customers to offer a minimum of 20 percent tips — under the watchful gaze of the beneficiary — have practically removed limitations to tipping those workers. And “there may be research displaying that folks who pay with a credit score card seem to pay a piece more than people who pay with coins,” stated W. Michael Lynn, a professor of food and beverage control at Cornell University.


But credit score card companies fee traders a rate for processing hints, so there are nonetheless companies — most considerably nail and splendor salons — that largely don’t allow clients leave digital guidelines. This turned into trouble for Mr. Diaz (he asked now not to use his first name because he becomes now not legal through his agency to talk to the click), a hairdresser of 22 years who works in Chelsea. His tip profits dipped extensively till he signed up for Venmo, an app that enables individual-to-man or woman cash transfers.

Mr. Diaz said that his younger customers rarely have paper money and frequently say they’ll tip him the subsequent time they see him. His customers advocated him to join Venmo, and his tip earnings are now lowered back to in which it was, he stated.

Though Venmo is famous for peer-to-peer transfers, many other apps, inclusive of Bravo, Tips, and Tiphanie, have sprung up in the latest years especially aimed toward presenting virtual tips for workers who rely upon coins. But thus far, none have reached the extent of enormous adoption necessary to make an actual dent.

“The problem is both events, receiver, and giver, should have the app for this to work, and it’s hard to create an incentive that causes both groups to join up,” Mr. Lynn said. “Nobody has figured out a way to a restoration that trouble.”

About the author

Related Posts